What people are saying:
- Facebook User: It’s Sharia law. These religious laws. Laws governing women. Draconian punishments for minor infractions, including protests. Police executing citizens in the street. What’s the difference between Texas and any of the worst hellholes in the Middle East like Afghanistan, Syria, or Iran?
- Facebook User: Next they will fight over what bible to use, how it should be taught, and who should teach it. Trust me as a teacher they would not want me teaching that lesson. Bah ha ha ha
- Facebook User:
- Facebook User: A little history lesson that maybe law makers can learn from since they live in an alternate universe and are blind what the ramifications of this could be….
In the mid 19th c there were riots that killed over 20 people in Philadelphia — over which Bible should be used in public schools. The Catholics were pissed the King James Version was the only version offered. The local bishop asked the board of controllers to let catholic kids read their version as well. The Protestant majority took it as an “affront to their religious beliefs” and an “attack on the Bible itself” (This is also the reason catholic schools exist)
Does this all sound familiar?
1. The “Christians are under attack” myth
In the five months before the riots, nativist groups spread a deliberate lie that Catholics were trying to remove the Bible from public schools entirely. Today’s equivalent is the persistent right-wing claim that religious freedom is being systematically erased from public education, a grievance manufactured with the same cynical precision.
2. Anti-immigrant hysteria
No elaboration needed. The targets have changed, but the playbook hasn’t. The great-great-grandchildren of the Irish and German immigrants once scapegoated are now enthusiastically running the same play against the next wave of newcomers.
3. Local leaders rallying around a manufactured threat
In 1844, 94 Philadelphia clergymen united around a pledge to defend Protestant education against what they called “the assaults of Romanism.” In 2023, Texas Rep. Chip Roy declared: “Save Texas, Save America from Sharia Law jihad.” Different century, identical architecture of fear.
The deepest irony? The riots weren’t just about Bible translations. They were fueled by the same virulent anti-immigrant sentiment we’re watching play out now with the descendants of those very targeted immigrants leading the charge. Same story, 175 years later, almost word for word. Some lessons, it seems, we’re determined never to learn.
- Secular Education Association: Facebook User YES. All of this! It’s almost word for word what is happening now. Thank you for elaborating on this history! 👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻
- Facebook User: Secular Education Association absolutely ! Thanks for letting me share it ☺️
- Facebook User: Indoctrination is a form of control.
View original post on Facebook
Leave a Reply