This is not solidarity. It’s content.

Yesterday, Friendly Atheist posted a graphic declaring that religious instruction does not belong in the public school day.

Great. We’ve been saying that for years.

But there was no information. No explanation of what LifeWise is doing inside public school districts. No resources for affected parents. No mention of the investigations, records, maps, curriculum analysis or organizing that made much of what is now publicly known about LifeWise possible.

And, once again, no mention of us.

That omission is especially infuriating because when LifeWise sued our co-founder Zach Parrish in 2024 for exposing its curriculum, Hemant Mehta did cover us.

He just did not cover us well.

He declared that LifeWise would “almost certainly win.” He reduced a fight over parental access, public accountability and religious instruction during the school day to a straightforward copyright dispute. His coverage was dismissive of our legal defense, dismissive of our organization and dismissive of what we were trying to accomplish.

That kind of coverage did not help a tiny grassroots parent organization being sued by a multimillion-dollar religious corporation. It amplified the idea that we had recklessly picked a fight we could not win and that the outcome was practically predetermined.

He was wrong about what this fight could achieve. The lawsuit did not end with LifeWise crushing Zach or collecting damages from him.

It ended with neither party paying the other—and with LifeWise legally bound to make its complete and current curriculum available to anyone who requests it. Access is provided for 48 hours at a time, requests can be made repeatedly, and LifeWise can no longer simply deny access to the materials.

Parents have that access today because Zach fought back.

Because we did not fold.

Because our organization kept working while people with much larger platforms underestimated us, dismissed us or ignored us.

Now Friendly Atheist can post a LifeWise bus, say “indoctrination,” collect thousands of engagements and move on.

We do not get to move on.

We are the parents answering frightened families. We are filing the records requests. We are reading the curriculum. We are tracking the legislation, money, facilities, political alliances and district entanglement. We are building the tools that allow the public to understand what a meme never will.

So yes, religious instruction should happen at home or in church—not during the public school day.

But the people doing the actual work to defend that principle deserve more than being erased from the story after being publicly written off.


What people are saying:

  • Secular Education Association: For context: Friendly Atheist’s previous coverage of us came in July 2024, after LifeWise sued our co-founder Zach Parrish for publishing its curriculum. The article framed LifeWise as likely to “almost certainly win,” while giving little weight to the transparency fight at the heart of the case or the reality of a small parent-led organization being sued by a multimillion-dollar religious nonprofit.

    That prediction also failed to capture what the case ultimately accomplished. The lawsuit was dismissed through a settlement requiring LifeWise to provide its complete and current curriculum to anyone who requests it. Access is limited to 48 hours at a time, but it may be requested repeatedly.

    So seeing Friendly Atheist post a vague LifeWise meme now—with no information, no resources, no history, and no acknowledgment of the people who actually fought for that transparency—is more than a little frustrating.

    His original coverage:
    “LifeWise Academy sues Ohio man who posted its Bible curriculum online”
    https://www.friendlyatheist.com/p/lifewise-academy-sues-ohio-man-who

    Settlement coverage:
    https://www.wosu.org/politics-government/2024-12-27/lifewise-academy-settles-copyright-lawsuit-with-parent-who-posted-curriculum-online

  • Facebook User: This happens way too often. I’m so sorry.
  • Facebook User: The truth! I have followed FA for awhile and it appears to be all opinions and insults, no substance.
  • Facebook User: Public schools are the best in my opinion. You have your opinion and that is fine your choice.But don’t make stuff up and label other people’s choices.

View original post on Facebook

Discover more from Secular Education Association

Subscribe now to keep reading and get access to the full archive.

Continue reading