đ¨ INDIANA: THIS IS WHAT âVOLUNTARYâ CAN LOOK LIKE FOR THE CHILD WHO DOESNâT GO.
As LifeWise Academy explores expansion into Monroe and Brown counties in Indiana, Indiana Public Media WFIU Public Radio spoke with SEAâs Zachary Parrish about what families should know before the program arrives.
And Zach knows firsthand what this can look like for the children who donât participate..
At his daughterâs public school in Ohio, LifeWise was incorporated directly into the specials rotation:
âThey handed me the classroom rotation schedule, which included LifeWise. Like it was right there, listed with all of the specials classes: gym, art, music, LifeWise.â
Zach called the school and asked a pretty basic question:
My daughter isnât going to LifeWise. What is she going to be doing?
The answer?
đ¨ âWeâre shoving her into the gymnasium to go read by herself for an entire period.â
And THAT is a part of this conversation that gets lost every time someone says:
âItâs voluntary.â
đWhat happens to the children who stay?
đWhat happens when Bible instruction appears alongside gym, art and music on the schoolâs own rotation schedule?
đWhat message does it send when the alternative for a child whose family declines religious instruction is to sit alone in a gym and read?
One Indiana parent interviewed for the story put the larger issue plainly:
âOur public schools are open to everybody, and they should remain spaces that are for absolutely everybody of all religions and no religion at all.â
đđđđ
And Indiana families should be asking these questions now, as LifeWise explores expansion into Monroe and Brown counties.
Released-time religious instruction may be permitted â and Indiana law now requires qualifying students to be released when their parents request it â but that does not erase a public schoolâs responsibility to the children who remain.
No child should be treated like the leftover kid because their family chose not to participate in religious instruction.
đ MONROE COUNTY, INDIANA.
đ BROWN COUNTY, INDIANA.
Pay attention.
đŁ PUBLIC SCHOOLS BELONG TO EVERYONE
Full Indiana Public Media/WFIU-WTIU report in the comments. đ
What people are saying:
- Secular Education Association: One piece of context we want to add to Zachâs story: his daughter was in third grade. She was coming off the COVID years and struggling to read independently.
So when her family chose not to send her to LifeWise, the schoolâs plan was to put her in the gym to read by herself for an entire period.
Think about that.
That was her education. That was her school day. That was time she could have been receiving instruction and support learning how to READ.
She didnât need somewhere to be stored while other children went to Bible class. She needed her public school to educate her.
This is why âbut itâs voluntaryâ does not answer the question.
What happens to the children who stay matters and we will NEVER shut up about it.
- Facebook User: Secular Education Association What I’m surprised they didn’t have her public school 3rd grade Language Arts teacher work with her 1:1 to improve her reading skills, while the rest of the class was at LW. Her school teacher wouldn’t have been the LW instructor, and the school in general shouldn’t have been using LW in place of the SEL (Social -Emotional Learning) component & character development lessons, often taught by the school guidance counselor, that might be required now in public school.
- Facebook User: Facebook User that time is the teacher’s break. A tutor should be working with the child.
- Secular Education Association: đ READ THE FULL STORY:
âReligious ed for Monroe, Brown County public schools? A group is exploring itâ â WFIU/WTIU News, Indiana Public Media
- Facebook User: NO MORE RELIGION IN PUBLIC SCHOOLS
- Facebook User: The entire concept of releasing children for religious instruction from the scheduled school is just wrong!!!
- Facebook User: This retired teacher thinks Lifewise is wasting all of the childrenâs time.
- Secular Education Association: Facebook User HARD agree!
- Facebook User: Facebook User Perhaps, but what about SEL where a staff member teaches character development lessons, then has the class do yoga, in an effort to teach students how to reglate their emotions? (Personally I don’t have a problem w/it,although there are some, such as those who send their kids to LW, who think doing yoga whatsoever is a ‘religion.’ smh)
- Facebook User: Facebook User This retired Librarian thinks it’s not Constitutional.
- Facebook User: Facebook User I believe very strongly that families should pursue religious instruction OUTSIDE of that six hours we have for academic instruction.
Idk what happened in the eight years since I retired. As a former union rep, this would have rankled me to no end. - Facebook User: Facebook User in my small village we have a Hindu temple, a Greek Orthodox monastery, a Buddhist temple, a Sikh temple, a Catholic Church, a Methodist church and thatâs just off the top of my head. And we haveLifewise in our schools đ¤Ź
- Facebook User: It will only get worse from here unless it is stopped
- Facebook User: An entire period for an optional off property activity? Thatâs minutes that can be added to other course periods.
Every minute counts in public education.
I hope Zach and the community were able to fight that- Secular Education Association: Facebook User Unfortunately, it wasnât stopped. Zachâs daughter no longer attends school in Defiance, Ohio- but his fight over what happened to her grew into this organization. LifeWise still operates at Defiance Elementary, where the latest enrollment figure we can verify is 830 studentsânearly 79% of the entire school. And weâre still fighting.
- Facebook User: That’s just ridiculous. I wouldn’t trust any of them to take my child off campus. What if they are being molested? It is not a far-fetched question, either.
- Facebook User: Well I do know of one district that only does it at lunch and recess. That being said I donât think it belongs during the school day. Should be before or after school. Not during.
- Secular Education Association: Facebook User there are several schools/districts that only pull children out during lunch and recess. BUT the majority of these programs are happening during âspecialsâ like Art, Music, Library, and P.E. And we agree.
- Facebook User: Facebook User, parents should request that they only leave during lunch and recess. And if Lifewise can’t keep to that schedule, sowwy…đ¤ˇââď¸
- Facebook User: Facebook User Should be on Sunday, at Sunday School. Why are they not invading churches instead of public schools? It’s not an accident.
- Facebook User: They often choose the library period, as Lifewise said, because kids can ” get a book anytime.” That negates the fact that many school library media specialists teach during that time — how to do in-house and online research, evaluate websites, and cite sources, among other topics. I wish teachers would do cool projects with the kids who stay, so they can tell the Lifewise kids what they missed.
- Facebook User: Iâd love to be the teacher for the students who opt out! I would provide them with a really fun activity so theyâd have bragging rights. They should NOT be sent to a gym to read! Thereâs nothing wrong with reading, but instructional time is instructional time. I had a number of Muslim students when I taught. This would have made me so angry!
- Facebook User: That sounds like a scheduling problem by the school.
- Facebook User: Facebook User state law in Ohio stipulated the schools districts have to “collaborate” with the organization over release times. Functionally, this means the individuals school has almost no say in it at all
- Facebook User: Facebook User Thankfully, this has not been a problem where I am.
- Facebook User: Facebook User That sounds like a spineless Superintendent problem.
- Facebook User: Facebook User I’m in ohio. I was told recently that originally it was optional for the school districts. But now it is mandatory or the state will withhold certain funds for not participating in the LifeWise program!
Our governor signed some sort of Bill in the past year or two mandating that the school systems allow Christian instruction in the schools. I’m against it. One question that I’ve not seen is do these parents go to church at all? Are these children’s parents active in any type of organized religion? Are they just sending their children for bragging rights? This isn’t what Christianity is supposed to be about in any way at all!
- Facebook User: I know yâall have a lot of irons in the fire now and always, but are yâall also pushing back against programs like FCA in public schools? I had a huge argument with two women the other day about it and their go to excuses are always âYou are impeding OUR kids religious freedom.â And âYOUR kid doesnât have to participate.â It makes me so mad that they think they can always be the center of attention and their religion and beliefs is all that matters. Thank you for doing the work yâall are doing.
- Facebook User: Facebook User FCA doesn’t take the place of Specials. It’s not during the school day. I’m not a fan of the organization, and I’m sure it’s changed a lot since I was in school, and not for the better.
- Facebook User: Facebook User I get that itâs a before/after school thing, but with these people if you give them an inch theyâll take a mile. Itâs only a matter of time before the before/after school changes to during school.
- Facebook User: Facebook User They did the “Meet Me At The Pole” thing for a few years. Performative nonsense. I once asked the sponsor why they weren’t praying in their inner rooms.
- Facebook User: Facebook User our child was told they could not be a part of fca because they were catholic. End of story
- Facebook User: Facebook User that is crazy. I honestly didnât know that Protestants looked down on Catholics so much until I was in my mid 20s when I moved to the east Texas Bible Belt as a non-practicing catholic. I told whoever asked me that I was such and they always looked at me like I had three heads.
- Facebook User: Back in the 1950s it was called released time. Last class period of the day, kids left early for religious instruction. Those of us who didn’t go had to sit quietly in a classroom, no talking, no moving from our seats. It sure felt like punishment!
- Facebook User: My parents fought, and lost, this fight 70 years ago in my rural Ohio elementary school. It is beyond belief that we find ourselves here again. One question I have not seen answered: who is profiting from Lifewise, and how much?
- Facebook User: Facebook User take a look at Lifewise income đł
- Facebook User: Facebook User lifewise is it’s own non profit, it is not owned by any other group.
- Facebook User: Facebook User non profit my rear!
- Facebook User: How can schools incorporate it into their day when it contradicts state standards for subjects such as history and science, and their staff and teachers don’t have background checks?
- Facebook User: Once you let them in, they’ll run everything. It’ll be a tax supported religious school. You can’t let them get their foot in the door.
- Facebook User: Parents too damn lazy to be responsible for their children’s religious education. They should be ashamed for stealing from public education.
- Facebook User: Lifewise is cult like and has no business in the school period. What religious beliefs are they teaching and who are these people teaching it.
- Facebook User: It is laughable to worry about what these kids are exposed to when no one cares what Christian kids are exposed to with no option given.
As long as only what you believe is taught it is good.


Leave a Reply