Ok, enough with the bullshit — here’s what it’s really about:
👉They tried to create a taxpayer-funded religious charter school in Oklahoma.
It was Catholic.
The Oklahoma Supreme Court stopped it.
They took it to the U.S. Supreme Court. The Court split 4–4.
So the school stayed dead — but they didn’t get a nationwide answer to the question they were really asking:
Can states be FORCED to allow religious organizations to run taxpayer-funded charter schools?
So here we go again…This time, the school is Jewish. And if you’re thinking these are two completely separate stories, that’s the part you’re missing.
-Brett Farley was on the board of St. Isidore.
Now he’s a founding board member of Ben Gamla. He is also the Executive Director of the Catholic Conference of Oklahoma. 👀
-Ben Gamla founder Peter Deutsch supported St. Isidore at the Supreme Court.
-The lawyers were lined up before Ben Gamla even submitted its Oklahoma application.
-And this wasn’t exactly being driven by Oklahoma’s Jewish community. Established Jewish leaders and organizations in Oklahoma opposed the proposal. Tulsa Jewish leaders said the Florida-based group behind Ben Gamla had not meaningfully consulted the local Jewish community before trying to establish the school.
This is not random. St. Isidore failed to produce the nationwide precedent its supporters wanted. Now the constitutional question is back with a different school and a different religion.
🚨And here’s why you should give a damn:
If Ben Gamla ultimately wins the principle it is arguing for, the result is NOT:
“One Jewish charter school gets to open in Oklahoma.”
👉The principle would apply to religion generally.
That means the same constitutional argument becomes available to Christian organizations seeking taxpayer funding to operate religious charter schools. 💁♀️
Including the movement that already tried it with St. Isidore. And this time?
A federal judge has preliminarily ruled in Ben Gamla’s favor. 😡😡😡
So when you see a headline about Oklahoma being required to allow a “Jewish charter school,” understand what is actually being decided.
🚨 This could determine whether states can keep religious instruction OUT of their publicly funded charter-school systems at all.
As in: every Tom, Dick, and Christian nationalist Harry could try to open a religious charter school, teach kids their religion — and make YOU, the taxpayer, pay for it.
That’s what’s at stake here.
Different school.
Same network.
Same constitutional fight.
Reporting/photo: Nuria Martinez-Keel, Oklahoma Voice Receipts in the comments.
What people are saying:
- Secular Education Association: 👉And one more important piece of context: established Jewish leaders in Oklahoma opposed Ben Gamla. Leaders representing Tulsa synagogues, the Jewish Federation of Tulsa, the local Jewish day school and other Jewish institutions said the Florida-based organization behind the proposal had not meaningfully consulted Oklahoma’s established Jewish community. The Jewish Federation of Greater Oklahoma City also opposed the religious-charter-school effort.
That matters when this is presented simply as “Oklahoma’s Jewish community wants a Jewish charter school.” That is not what happened.
Tulsa’s Jewish community pushes back on Oklahoma Jewish charter school proposal
- Secular Education Association: 📌 RECEIPTS:
The reporting/photo used in our graphic is from Facebook User. Their reporting confirms that Brett Farley — executive director of the Catholic Conference of Oklahoma and a board member of the overturned St. Isidore Catholic charter school — became a founding board member of Ben Gamla. It also reports that Ben Gamla’s founders planned from the beginning to take the rejection to federal court.
Oklahoma board rejects Jewish charter school, braces for a court battle
Jewish Telegraphic Agency went even further: Ben Gamla’s legal team was assembled before the application was submitted, and the group specifically chose Oklahoma to bring a federal challenge to the constitutional question left unresolved when SCOTUS split 4–4 in the St. Isidore case.
And here is the September 24 ruling: a federal judge granted Ben Gamla a preliminary injunction against enforcement of Oklahoma’s prohibition on religious public charter schools while the lawsuit continues.
National Ben Gamla Jewish Charter School Foundation v. Shellem
Reuters on the ruling:
This case is ongoing. The September 24 ruling is not a final judgment.


Leave a Reply